RANGER AGAINST WAR: Good God <

Thursday, June 07, 2007

Good God




Folks don’t like the truth. That’s the point. It’s easier lyin’.
Stops us havin’ to face up to trouble when it comes along;

to do wrong insteada right.”


--Jesse Custer, The Preacher

_____________



The quote is spoken by fictitious Texan Preacher Jesse Custer, protagonist of the eponymous graphic novel series.

Jesse is a believer, but he's been pretty screwed up by his upbringing in a dysfunctional pious American family. So he becomes a warfighter, of sorts. It is an altogether uneasy feeling.


Now look at all these happy campers on the cover of this month's
VFW magazine. Since the front and center person is a chaplain, then God is surely smiling on the forces of goodness and democracy, yes?


I wonder, however, why Chaplain Morris is wearing a Combat Action Badge.

The last time Ranger checked into the net chaplains were non-combatants, per the Geneva Conventions. How would a chaplain be part of a military operation as a functioning member and still maintain non-combatant status?

Chaplains have earned every award for valor that exists in the U.S. military and this is just, fair and equitable, as they often provide spiritual comfort in some pretty dicey environments. Ranger salutes this service and their valor, but putting a CAB on their chest is totally inappropriate. These personnel are not war fighters.

Awarding chaplains the CAB is a militarization of a spiritual function. Medics must be exposed to combat to perform their duties, but this is not true of chaplains.

If chaplains are forward during operations, it is to do God's work; they should not be participants. Putting CAB's on chaplains strikes Ranger as fascistic in all senses of the word.

Labels: ,

14 Comments:

Blogger Lurch said...

Putting CAB's on chaplains strikes Ranger as fascistic in all senses of the word.


And your point would be?

Thursday, June 7, 2007 at 10:46:00 PM GMT-5  
Blogger rangeragainstwar said...

lurch,

I try to compensate for my lack of subtlety with volume.

You're right, I'm being redundant here.

Friday, June 8, 2007 at 8:07:00 AM GMT-5  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

+++ militarization of a spiritual function+++

Ah, but you see, that fits right in with the politicization of religion in general that is going on. Oddly, while America decries this occurrence in Muslim countries, it doesn't even notice it at home!

Gotta link up that God-Country-Fu...uh, Leader, ya know?

Friday, June 8, 2007 at 10:02:00 AM GMT-5  
Blogger rangeragainstwar said...

labrys,

I believe you're suggesting some hypocrisy in the U.S. of A.. . .?

We'll pray on this, sister labrys, and get back with you.

Friday, June 8, 2007 at 12:12:00 PM GMT-5  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Gott mit uns. And now they are building a permanent base in Babylon. Reads more and more like a HP Lovecraft novel.

Saturday, June 9, 2007 at 10:25:00 AM GMT-5  
Blogger rangeragainstwar said...

fnord,

Lovecraftian, you think? May be even more nefarious than I imagine. And that's pretty bad.

Saturday, June 9, 2007 at 3:16:00 PM GMT-5  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

The CAB simply indicates that one was in the midst of combat.

Read up on it: http://www.army.mil/symbols/combatbadges/Action.html

Chaplains have been and will be in the midst of combat, being enganged by the enemy, especially in todays contemporary operating enviornment. To snipe a Chaplain is right out of the Qaeda play book. The USA Today reported this last summer.

And, for instance, this year a Chaplain was shot while praying over a Soldier who was wounded from an IED. That's ministry at it's finest in my book. If a Chaplain qualifies for it, then it only indicates to me how committed to ministry Chaplains are today.

Paul

www.worthmysalt.blogspot.com

Friday, July 13, 2007 at 10:43:00 PM GMT-5  
Blogger rangeragainstwar said...

paul,

It seems we should not place chaplains that far forward, if they are taking gunfire. That seems a blasphemous contradiction, putting a man of the cloth in such a position.

If it's in the playbook, and we've read it, then why don't we respond? The correct response is not always, Hey diddle diddle, up the middle.

Jim may have more to say when he's back,

Lisa

Friday, July 13, 2007 at 11:05:00 PM GMT-5  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Lisa,

Since 2003 this war has been asymmetical in nature, and because it is so urbarn will continue to be this way.

There is no telling when combat is going to spontaneously break out. The Army does a good job taking care of their Chaplains. We haven't lost NOT one in the GWOT.

I don't have a CAB, but a good Chaplain friend of mine was doing real ministry when he earned his. It may not mean anything to you, but it speaks volumes to the troops.

Paul

Saturday, July 14, 2007 at 9:57:00 AM GMT-5  
Blogger rangeragainstwar said...

Paul,

I am eminently respectful of the awarding of a tab or a badge. It means a great deal to me, and I can imagine what it means to the troops.

I understand your argument for the necessarily unpredictable nature of UW. Especially for this reason, I stake my position here: on the fundamental inherent wrongness of this war.

Engagements such as this should not be undertaken/created by choice, and this one was, aided by fomented hysteria.

I believe it is horrific and criminal to subject any of our servicebpeople to this mess, much less members of the clergy.

My heart bleeds for the senseless, unending nature of this behemoth of our own creation.

To me, it is a sort of grand comic-tragedy to watch as we send our people down the death chute of these roads in the desert to be maimed and mortally wounded, for people who don't want what we offer, and then send a chaplain behind to minister to this created tragedy.

It leaves a very poor taste in my mouth,

Lisa

Saturday, July 14, 2007 at 10:59:00 AM GMT-5  
Blogger rangeragainstwar said...

The chaplain you report was shot while administering to the ied wounded is a finest example of the military dedication, and should be rewarded with an appropriate valor award as was done in all other wars.

Non-combatants have won the Medal of Honor on numerous occasions and this is correct. Giving a combat badge to a non-combatant is idiotic and inappropriate. These people are not warfighters.

Jim

Sunday, July 15, 2007 at 12:53:00 PM GMT-5  
Blogger rangeragainstwar said...

Paul,

Some more thoughts (It's possible for an old Ranger to have more than one thought in a day):

Chaplains are non-combatants and should remain so. The troops may like a balls-up chaplain, but how is that different than Sadr's men's attitude towards him? WWJD?

Chaplains are there for spiritual welfare and not as tactical assets. I admire your devotion and understanding of the troops, but fighting doesn't necessarily reflect Christian values.

What is good for the soul is not good for the army.

Jim

Sunday, July 15, 2007 at 12:58:00 PM GMT-5  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

It seems to you that the awarding of a combat action badge is akin to doing battle with the enemy. However according to army
regulation, it is a badge to indicate one was performing their duties in good form while being under enemy fire.

Reg translation: "Good job for staying alive when the fecal matter hit the fan."

Throughout this war CABs and CIBs have been awarded for a wide spectrum of what is considered combat action. For some it was earned due to a serious exchange of lead. Others were merely in the vicinity of random indirect fire or part of an operation where combat was seen, but not all awardees had "experienced." It boils down to being at the right place and the right time...or is it the wrong place...?

As prior infantry I will always have a high regard for those with the EIB or EFMB, because they earned a tough badge. Chaplains can never earn those badges, but they can certainly perform their duties while under enemy fire. And last I checked Iraq and A-stan are entirely red zones.

God bless,
Iraq Vet

Tuesday, September 22, 2009 at 10:56:00 PM GMT-5  
Blogger rangeragainstwar said...

Anon,

The CAB may be awarded to Chaplains according to the Army regs.

It's my position that Non combatants are not non-combatants, even if you hang combat awards on their chests. That's my opinion, right or wrong.

Yes Chaplains earn valor awards, and rightly so if they are administering religious rights under fire.

IMHO the CAB should require offensive action against an armed enemy. Since Chaplains are not offensive combatants, then they should not get a CAB.

Either one works for god or the manuever commander, and contrary to Army belief, these are not one entity.

I am not questioning anybody's service when I discuss these awards. I really don't care who shot John. As for chaplains, when did god become an offensive part of any army, Islamic or Christian.

The CMB is a combat award, of sorts, that was for being a combat medic. These people used to be non-combatants but this isn't to be true any longer.

jim

Thursday, September 24, 2009 at 12:37:00 PM GMT-5  

Post a Comment

<< Home