RANGER AGAINST WAR: The Fourth Estate <

Saturday, February 07, 2009

The Fourth Estate


Went across the river and I lay down to sleep
When I woke up, put the shackles on my feet

It takes a worried man to sing a worried song

I'm worried now, but I won't be worried long

--Worried Man Blues, A. P. Carter

______________

Yesterday I discovered my brother-in-law had been laid off from his erstwhile recession-proof job. My sis says they are paying over $1,000 to keep their COBRA health benefits for the time being.

They are Good Americans. He works a hard 40-hour-week; she volunteers at various charities, sitting on the board and trying to make a positive change in their community. Since she now has to work for pay, the volunteering is on the back burner.

Journalist Bill Moyers featured bloggers Glenn Greenwald and Jay Rosen on his Journal program last night, both of whom agreed that the Washington Press corps is complicit in maintaining the political staus quo. There is little separating Left from Right, and The Fourth Estate is on the inside every bit as much as the politicos they cover. They have a script which carries from one administration to the next.

Why is the economy not front and center every day of the week? Why are we inundated with Tom Daschle and the Octuplet mother? My sister doesn't care that elections were held in Afghanistan, she wants to know if her surgery will be covered.

As President Obama settles into a middle path after promising radical change, so too, the press follows its established role. Neither the press nor the politicians want to shake things up, lest they find themselves on the outside. Both guests agreed that the power of protest -- whether written or street-style -- is what is necessary to shake the powers that be out of their comfort zone.

But the press will not cover protest, so the public imagines everyone else is inert and impotent. Protesters, if given any ink at all, are portrayed as marginal elements. Moyers' impassioned closing remarks are noteworthy, especially coming as they do from a gentle man and a minister:

As Washington obsessed all week over the fate of one nominee to the cabinet, and as we watched hearings about the failure of watchdog agencies going to sleep on the job, we heard almost nothing of the people across the country suffocating in the wreckage of their lives. Some of us born in the Depression still remember the song made famous by the Carter Family singers, called the "Worried Man Blues".

"I went across that river and I lay down to sleep. When I woke up there were shackles on my feet."

The day my father was fired from his job at Manly's Appliance Store, he came walking home as if he had shackles on his feet. I still remember the look on his face. He wasn't yet 50, but had suddenly turned old, the way a lot of people look today who are losing their jobs. Their stomachs are knotted with fear as the life they had come to expect is fading fast. Not because of their own failures but because our political and financial elites rigged the economy for their own advantage.

John F. Kennedy famously said, "Life is unfair," and so it is. But it wouldn't feel as unfair if the shackles wound up instead on the well-heeled feet of Wall Street and Washington's elect. That's the change we need, the change we can really believe in.

Labels: , ,

7 Comments:

Blogger Peter of Lone Tree said...

The BRITISH Telegraph:
Bankers 'used corporate credit cards to pay for prostitutes':
Kristin Davis alleges that prosecutors in the Manhattan District Attorney's office decided not to pursue any of them even though she provided evidence.

Davis, who admitted charges last year of running a prostitution business employing more than 100 women, told ABC News that the men included a senior executive of a top media company, a banker who spent $41,600 and the chief executive of one of America's largest private equity firms.


More at the link.

Saturday, February 7, 2009 at 10:24:00 PM EST  
Blogger The Minstrel Boy said...

billy's in the parlor
holdin' hands with sue
nicky's at the front door
trying to come on through

i'm hiding here in the closet
oh lord, what will i do?

i'm worried now,
but i won't be worried long


john stewart

more and more, i think that the only thing which will get their attention would be a solidarity type of general strike.

pick a day. everybody stay home.

the government workers of california have begun to do their furlough. two days a week they don't go into work. in the case of prison guards, teachers, nurses, and other folks whose job numbers are mandated by law, they go ahead and work, but they will recieve two days of "comp" time (which is time off on the books that they never let you use, on account of your numbers on the job are mandated by law and stuff).

actually, paying for hookers with bailout money at least keeps the money in the country. if they spent it on consumer goods they would be funding china and other nafta members. hookers, domestic beer, and marijuana. buy american yo.

too the barricades. the guillotine is harsh, but she speaks truth.

Sunday, February 8, 2009 at 11:45:00 AM EST  
Blogger rangeragainstwar said...

POLT,

OK, but did they get frequent flier miles?

jim

Sunday, February 8, 2009 at 12:34:00 PM EST  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Ranger, why do you think they call it the "Fourth Estate"? The press—or media, if you will—has always fancied itself to be part of the government. If you track back to the writings of fools such as Walter Lippman, they believe themselves to be the continuity in government, the element that never goes away, even as politicians come and go. Once you understand that, it all makes sense.

Many in the press were once public-spirited, but most of that went away once it became clear that the public itself didn't care about the intricacies of government, but would rather be entertained. This coincided nicely with the increasing media ownership of oligarchs who'd rather have an uninformed populace cheering for certain government agendas and consuming shitty products.

As a money-making enterprise, the press concerns itself with the requirements of the consumer. If the consumer doesn't care about governmental wrongdoing, the press won't care either. It's pretty much the same principle that led to domestic carmakers churning out gas-hog SUVs instead of energy-efficient vehicles. The market is everything.

Now, of course, we're bailing out the domestic car companies for their stupidity in doing exactly what we wanted. Won't matter in the long run: they've forgotten how to do the job right and the people who demanded the shitty cars can't afford cars anyway.

The same is happening with the press. They've catered to the lowest common denominator for so long that they've forgotten how to do a good job. And they're dying. Because of their corporate ownership, they're trying desperately to convince us that oligarchy is the way to go. But as the jobs go away, fewer people believe this anymore. One notes (with approval) that Murdoch took a huge loss on his holdings, which include Fox and the WSJ.

Make no mistake: the goal has always been concentration of power in just a few hands. And what's truly amazing about our nation is how many "smart" guys think that because they have a college degree and make, say, $100K a year, they have "made it" and should somehow identify with the moneyed class rather than with working Americans. This includes most "journalists."

Those "smart" guys are a paycheck away from disaster, but still identify with plutocrats stealing the nation blind. Go figure.

Jefferson had it right.

Sunday, February 8, 2009 at 10:56:00 PM EST  
Blogger Terrible said...

Great post. I'd be hard pressed if I had to think of someone I admire and respect more then Bill Moyers. His interviews with Joseph Campbell was the best thing I ever saw on a television.

Wednesday, February 11, 2009 at 10:20:00 AM EST  
Blogger Lisa said...

Publius,

I don't think most journalists earn anywhere near $100,000 year. Unfortunately, Americans are losing the taste for reading, everything is available online, and "entertainment journalists" know how to pander to the slavering masses.

Demand drives the supply. When the real reporters go, who will gather the news?

Wednesday, February 11, 2009 at 8:42:00 PM EST  
Blogger Lisa said...

Thanks, terrible. I respect Moyers. His interview with Campbell was great (I saw it on VHS).

When he concludes his program with such hard words, it's hard not to listen.

Wednesday, February 11, 2009 at 8:44:00 PM EST  

Post a Comment

<< Home