Mission Impossible
His stop-loss odyssey
went Kabul, morphine,
Ramstein, Stateside,
and back—round-robin
desert wrestling,
tag out, tag in
--Welcome Home, Troops!
Amit Majmudar
Cause I gonna make you see
There's nobody else here
No one like me
I'm special, so special
--Brass in Pocket,
The Pretenders
One step forward and two steps back
Nobody gets too far like that
One step forward and two steps back
This kind of dance can never last
--One Step Forward,
The Desert Rose Band
___________________
Let us do a check-in on the Phony War on Terror (PWOT ©) at lucky year 13, as President Obama sends more advisers to Syria in what looks very much like JFK's adviser gambit in the early years of the Vietnam War, the poster child counterinsurgency (COIN) failure.
First, a review: After the initial conventional invasion stage, the PWOT© became a COIN war, for lack of a better term. General Petraeus and his post-Vietnam thesis guided our participation, as if this time, we would really nation-build and win hearts and minds.
Hearts and minds, as if Vietnam could be redeemed and made into something of worth. COIN theory redux would modernize Galula, make what they tried to bury count, make it relevant for a new day.
But then the New COIN started looking like its own danse macbre. We forgot that it wasn't a war, and we were fighting the very people we came to democratize. COIN really isn't a very good way for the U.S. to win a war, or to help a people.
You cannot both fight people and nation build concurrently. Probably, we still do not realize that it is possible to nation build and to fight insurgents, but the process must occur consecutively. It is impossible to fight, kill and destroy while also attempting to build; the concepts are mutually exclusive.
The luster fell away from the erstwhile Golden Boy, General Petraeus, and his vaunted COIN theory has been folded and put back under the trundle bed, like an old Mission Impossible VHS tape. So where does that leave hearts and minds and nation building, as the United States trudges on in the quagmire that is the Not-Arab Spring?
The mask of nation-building has fallen away, as the U.S. realizes that was merely pretense for our frenzied occupation of places in which the U.S. had no legitimate reason to be. "Asymmetrical warfare" has also died a protracted death on the trash heap of a failed policy.
The U.S. is currently yoked to a slug-fest that makes less sense than did the tarted-up, new-and-improved COIN of once-wonder boy, Vietnam vet-manque, Mr. Petraeus.
Plus ça change, plus c'est la même chose.
Labels: asymmetrical warfare, COIN, counterinsurgency, general david petraeus, hearts and minds, military lies, syria